Thursday, 13 June 2019

Ibrox promotion may have been a big error - counting the cost


With today’s effective confirmation that Glenn Middleton will go out on loan to Doncaster for the new season, it has to call into question his promotion to Rangers’ first team squad in the first place.

We know Steven Gerrard was a rookie manager last campaign, and we tried to make allowances for that while marrying that up with the expectations of him, but we can’t help the suspicion Glenn Middleton was one he rather made a mess of.

Exposing him to European football as an unknown quantity, one who did well thanks to the ‘surprise’ factor of his presence, before he started getting expectations on his shoulders and struggling under the pressure of them, before fading totally to the bench.

Much was made last summer of Academy kids knocking on the front door, with then-new manager Gerrard confirming some of them were ready to stake a claim and would be promoted into the senior squad.

And Middleton was the beneficiary.

And we can’t help feeling a year of his development was wasted by burdening him with too much and then retreating him away too dramatically as he crumbled.

In truth, it takes an exceptionally special player to cope with the demands of playing for Rangers in the first place, and an even more special one at 18 as Middleton was then.

And we can’t avoid that nagging notion that rather than Middleton being promoted ahead of the rest, frankly no one should have been.

We have some promising talent down there in our Academy. Kennedy and Young-Coombes are two stand outs. Mebude has also had some little cameos in the first team.

But these kids are too green, too raw, and we really can’t see the point in promotion unless they’re truly extraordinary Ross McCrorie-style (and he too isn’t a guaranteed starter, far from it) to have the mental strength as well as ability to handle playing for Rangers at such a young age.

In short, we’d argue none of the Academy kids are ready for the first-team squad, and the best ones would benefit from loans out for senior football – it’s a policy Rangers have had in place for seasons, as all clubs do, but in future, learning from Middleton’s example, let’s not promote any kids to the senior squad unless we are absolutely sure they’re ready.

Middleton wasn’t. Hopefully his career isn’t set back too much from that.


4 comments:

  1. How can being involved with the first team squad be a set back? He continued to play with the youth teams whilst training with the first team and getting the exposure of match day squads. His goal against spartak Moscow away also shows that it was worth while.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think Middleton is a one trek pony for a winger. Teams sussed him out quickly and easily nullified his threat.
    The loan is a good move. It will give him first team games and we will be able to assess his suitability for the Rangers jersey. But I don't think he will make it. Wish him well and would love for him to prove me wrong!

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you're too fragile and delicate, you should not be playing for Rangers. A lot of us, at that age, were fearless and not scared to get stuck in, playing football. This generation of youth, seem cosseted and treated like they are about to break, at any moment. Murty is not the best man, to look after our youth. I believed that back then and still believe it, now. He'd rather make excuses for players and wipe their bums for them. Rangers need strong and aggressive, youth players. Fearless and hungry. Not wrapped up in cotton wool.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

By commenting on this article on Ibroxnoise.co.uk, you confirm you have read and understood the site terms, conditions, and moderation parameters (provided on the home page) of doing so.