Wednesday, 13 March 2019

"Not for us" - assessing the contenders for Rangers' POTY



So we’ve mentioned the POTY noms in passing today, and in this piece we’re going to go through them all and make our personal call. How many assessments do you agree with?

Allan McGregor:


A legitimate winner already before the nominations were announced, McGregor was the best signing last summer and he wasn’t even technically by Gerrard. Bringing the best Rangers goalie since Goram (even surpassing Klos in our opinion) back was a masterstroke and he’s repaid a great deal of the past misdemeanours by sheer performances. Some stupendous saves this season, McGregor is a worthy nomination and would be a very valid winner.

James Tavernier:

His stats are beyond denial but he’s by no means a universally-loved player – Tavernier’s captaincy remains a topic of division due to his lack of leadership, and his defending at best is patchy. His assists and goals are tremendous and he definitely has an ardent core base of support among our fans, but the fact our straw poll recently indicated only one reply of dozens/hundreds would have him win the honour rather makes the point for us.

Ryan Jack:


He’s had, overall, a very, very good season. Some titanic displays from maybe one of the most improved players under Steven Gerrard, Jack has become a justified starter and has even evolved his game into central and attacking midfield with great success. Not too many would be outraged if he won the award overall.

Ryan Kent:


Not for us. Regulars to the site will know we have a huge amount of time for Kent, but unfortunately while his superb displays absolutely dazzle us, he’s had many more average ones. Can’t play with Barisic and missed two months+ through injury. He’s currently on a bit of a lull, but that’s not why we wouldn’t give him the prize. He’s been stonking at times, but hasn’t done it anywhere near enough. A reluctant no, for us.

Alfredo Morelos:


Again, just no. No argument about his stats and contribution when in the zone, but way way too many Mr Hyde displays from Morelos, appalling discipline and petulance plus the inescapable fact he can’t seem to deliver enough on the big stage. We love this kid when he’s in the mood, but when he isn’t he’s an empty jersey and a complete liability.

Ibrox Noise’s award goes to:

Allan McGregor.

Very honourable mention to Ryan Jack who we’d be happy enough with too.

Who gets your nod, readers?


survey service

6 comments:

  1. McGregor. He showed up in ALL games. Morelos did not in the big ones.
    Against the sheep and the scum he was MIA.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Where would we be without Morelos goals? Hes won us more points than any other player. Fact!

    ReplyDelete
  3. McGregor all day long. Only consistent one who showed he wants to win the league and cups! The rest have just be average with no idea what the Rangers jersey demands!

    ReplyDelete
  4. McGregor by a mile and is the only one worthy of consideration. The rest have been far too inconsistent and have gone missing in the big games.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Freddo dosent turn up in big games & has like many of his team mates been guilty of letting the head drop when the going gets tough, Taverneir scores a lot of penalty, but IMO he is no leader therefor shouldn't be a captain, he wastes far too many crosses into the box & well his defending is well uts been the same for past 3 seasons, he plays ahead of Candeias for most of a match! I'd take what we can for both players in the summer! Then get shot of every single loan signing we have bar Defoe, he will pinch a few goals & his expirience is critical with the younger players! We desperately need a goal scoring MF, I hate to say it but would we maybe been better off keeping hold of Windass?? He scored 15+ from MF last season? Arfield is simply not clinical enough in front of goal, yet he has been one of the few consistent players for us.....Kent is another who at times is dazzling, but is a criminal offender for wasting passes & crosses! Last night he had so many hances to play Barisic in when he was overlapping & could get to the by line & in behind Aberdeen but instead would cut inside & hit his cross/pass off a dons defender! We have been guilty all season of failing to get in behind teams & trying to get the ball behind the opposition FBs & CB's.....but, I'm sure Stevie G will get it right in time

    ReplyDelete
  6. & I 100% agree with Ibrox noise, Macgregor hands down is only player who deserves to win this prize

    ReplyDelete

By commenting on this article on Ibroxnoise.co.uk, you confirm you have read and understood the site terms, conditions, and moderation parameters (provided on the home page) of doing so.