How controversial decision from Murty paid off


Regular readers of Ibrox Noise will be well aware we have advocated a change in formation from the 4-2-3-1 for some time now. While in itself decent enough, the formation does not get as much out the players as we would hope and has certainly been ineffective against the likes of Hibs, while isolating Jason Cummings.

As such we at the site wanted to revert to a 4 in the middle and a partnership up front, certainly given we do not lack the players to achieve it.

It is as if manager Graeme Murty listened, kind of. Today’s formation at Somerset Park was quite clearly a 4-4-2, albeit it was a diamond midfield rather than a bank of four, in order to accommodate Josh Windass at the apex.

Love or hate him, Windass scores and scores a lot, so whether his detractors like it or not, he is currently completely undroppable.

However, when we saw the formation confirmed, it was the first time in an age we were genuinely excited to see Rangers play. For as long as we can remember, we have dreaded seeing how the latest ill-fitting setup would confuse the team, but today we saw effectively the best XI we currently have in the best formation.

Our joy was doused a little when we realised Windass was not on the right  but through the middle and it was a diamond with Jamie Murphy on the left and Greg Docherty on the right, as Sean Goss sat at the rear, and indeed while that first half was certainly entertaining for the neutral, Rangers did not produce the quality of play we had hoped.

The diamond was struggling a touch to get into the game, and credit has to go to United for the high line they played, the high pressing they stuck at and the generally tough game they gave us. But once Jason Cummings scored that stunning second goal, it was a stroll for the light blues.

We would naturally have preferred the flat four, but there is definitely a growing immunity on the part of Windass, and Murty will always attempt to accommodate him – but when you look at the 1-6 scoreline, the team, personnel selection and formation are entirely justified.

What a difference playing more to players’ strengths makes. Sure, it was a closer first half than it should have been, but the second half was mostly a stroll and easily the most lethal Rangers have been up front in long enough.

The site’s regular commenter Robbie Wilson suggested pre-match all Rangers needed was good low crossing and this match would be a stroll. Well his wisdom was not far wrong for Jamie Murphy had a stellar match on the left and Greg Docherty was impressive on the right, while both Declan John and James Tavernier had extremely productive afternoons.

In the end 1-6 far from flattered Rangers – we really were that much better. And hopefully we kick on from here.


  1. Good result today but let's all keep our feet on the ground it was Ayr Utd not Man Utd.
    Time will tell if Murty sticks with this formation (Doubt It).
    First half Ayr pushed up and I thought played very well indeed,
    In fact played that well our front 3 were getting in each others way looking for space in behind.

    Well impressed with Docherty & Goss together, much more bite and controlled,

    Whole team played well today in very difficult conditions, Poor Escobar & Fods didnt do them any favours today!!

    Falkirk next at home.
    Onwards we March!!
    🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 Queens XI 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧

  2. Good time to try something new. Once they get used to it I see us rolling everyone over. Most cbs in the league struggle against morales or Cummings on there own, together they will bully every defence into submission

  3. True it was only Ayr United but there were some good signs we have at last got the type of players we need. Thought Murphy & Goss looked good and young Docherty was on it all over the pitch, he's going to be such good player for us. Tav was good and was John although his final pass is often poor. What a great goal from Cummings. Morelos …that miss, then a first class goal. When you think we have Dorran, Jack, Wallace and young McCrorie still to come back we have a strong squad and if we can sign these at the end of the season we should be able to put up a challenge next year. The cup is a possibility and so is finishing 2nd as we have to remember most of the players we brought in at the January window hadn't played much the first half of the season so are still getting match fit. More optimism now that we have had for a long time…

    We just need to off load as cost effectively as possible the Pedro players that must be costing the club $60k to £80K total a week in wages.

  4. Delighted! Just Delighted! I know it was only Ayr but we despatched them the way a Rangers team should! WATP 🇬🇧

Comments are closed.